New York: Alpha Books, 2011. Pp. xviii, 382. ISBN 978-1-61564-078-2.
Thousands of books have been written about the American Civil War. Where to
begin? Alan Axelrod seeks to answer that question in his Complete Idiot’s
Guide to the Civil War, which "will not tell you everything you need
to know about the Civil War [but] … will tell you all you need to know to
get started" (xvi).
Axelrod earned a doctorate in English at the University of Iowa and is currently
the president of Ian Samuel Group, a creative services and book packaging firm.
He has written several Idiot’s Guides and many other books and articles
on American history and military history in particular. In the present volume,
he leads the reader from an account of the origins of the Civil War through the
assassination of President Abraham Lincoln and Reconstruction to reflections on
the collective memory and lasting legacy of the conflict. To assist his
envisioned audience—novice students of the Civil War—he enhances his text with
illustrations, user-friendly symbols, and useful appendices on the relevant
vocabulary, personages, locations, and weapons of the war, as well as a succinct
bibliography. An added bonus is advice on visiting Civil War sites.
Axelrod gives the beginning student sufficient facts about key historical
actors, battles, tactics, and social and political matters to provide a sound
general basis from which to engage in more advanced and specific studies of the
war. One element of the book will benefit readers on all levels—a chapter
titled "Memory" dedicated to tying the past in with the present: "For despite
the often ill-tempered pitch and volume of recent divisive political rhetoric,
it remains a fact that the unity of the United States as one nation,
indivisible, was reaffirmed by the outcome of the Civil War. No wonder that the
epic struggle has figured as a subject of continual fascination to millions of
Americans" ( 333). In the first section of the chapter, "From Killing Fields to
Subdivisions," Axelrod sums up the importance of guidebooks like his, which
introduce the Civil War to a new and interested audience, highlighting its deep
and abiding place in American history.
No matter how
the landscape might change, the Civil War is unlikely ever to fade from our
collective memory. Since 1865, more than 65,000 books have been published on the
subject. To that add countless movies, television shows, and more than a dozen
popular interactive Civil War battle and strategy computer games. Thousands of
enthusiasts regularly meet at "Civil War Roundtables" to discuss arcane aspects
of the conflict, and an estimated 50,000 more periodically don impeccable
reproduction period uniforms and tote reproduction period weapons into
reenactments of key Civil War engagements (334).
Axelrod gives a good sense of the enduring fascination of the Civil War as well
as of the wide variety of available sources of information, from books and
articles to internet resources and the activities of reenactment groups and
other organizations.
A significant shortcoming of the book is the omission of a connected narrative in
favor of a simple arraying of facts in chronological and, less often, thematic
order. To be fair, Axelrod thereby succeeds in creating a reference tool that
will help readers begin to navigate the ocean of materials available for the
study of the Civil War. One nonetheless misses any semblance of a continuous
narrative line, as the book proceeds from one fact to the next. For instance,
the section "Seven Days and Another Bull Run" details Gen. John Pope’s takeover
of command in Virginia. There immediately follows a section, "Slow March to
Freedom," treating the emancipation efforts of the US government in the summer
of 1862. The reader is then wrenched back into military matters—the Battle of
Second Bull Run (127-29). Axelrod might better have finished dealing with
military matters and then moved on to a discussion of political issues. Some
contextualizing narrative explaining how different topics relate to each other
would have reduced the sense of too abrupt transitions among military and
political themes.
Like
other installments in the Complete Idiot’s Guide series, this book
achieves its aim of providing an accessible, general introduction to its
subject. It takes the reader through the essential themes of the Civil War, from
its preliminaries through the horrific four years of hostilities and their
aftermath to a consideration of the persistence of the war's legacy in the
nation's collection consciousness.